Where russian irredentism might be taking place

Rational choice accounts examine the decision-making processes of elites that initiate an irredentist conflict for instrumental purposes. Log in Subscribe to comment Why do I need to subscribe? However, once key states particularly the United States adopted a more robust stance, then both countries recognized the prewar borders of the Yugoslav republics.


At this point it would be very good to at least remember that we are not enemies. But the method of addressing the problem differs. That means: By contrast, ethnically based national identities, such as that found in Nazi Germany, more easily lend themselves toward a desire for unification. Unification of all Germans was one of its cornerstones.

Why Crimea is likely the limit of Greater Russia

There is, however, no Greater Switzerland. Also, we maintain that this will be possible only if the people of Belarus vote for such a solution in a plebiscite. Share On Twitter. By the mid-1960s the demographic majority that Protestants enjoyed in Northern Ireland ensured…. However, not all irredentism is fraught with such a threat. The continued discord between countries and states means that the potential for irredentist wars remains serious.

This is a space where subscribers can engage with each other and Globe staff. In this context it is clear, for instance, that the whole set of soft power tools that the Russian World had in Ukraine has been eliminated by the ongoing conflict. Irredentism often seeks to expand a given country to its maximum historical extent, regardless of whether the irredentists' ethnic group ever actually formed the majority in the territories in question.

One of the enduring truths of international relations going back to the ancient Greeks is that countries tend to respond to aggression by looking for allies as well as building up their defences. Is it worth doing that? Even if the minority in the contested region were to become entirely assimilated, the language would in many cases still have a large number of speakers in its respective nation-state and be in no danger of dying out.

For concerns on copyright infringement please see: Stephen Saideman is the Paterson chair in international affairs at Carleton University.

Irredentism and the Crisis of National Identity

Irredentism is the nationalist belief that a territory belonging to another country should be annexed for ethnic or historical reasons. Please note that our editors may make some formatting changes or correct spelling or grammatical errors, and may also contact you if any clarifications are needed.

The more tolerant they are, the more an irredentist state can get away with; if they are less tolerant, then an irredentist state is forced to temper or restrict its policies. The problem of a divided nation is multifactored and multifaceted. Written By: In a situation like this we would hardly be able to expect understanding on the other side, whether it be Kazakhstan or Ukraine.